Posterous theme by Cory Watilo

Filed under: Mute Math

Mute Math: A Christian Band or Does It Matter?


I found them. I finally found a new band that I really like: Mute Math. Back in the day, I would hear about new music from MTV (loved the show 120 Minutes) but now, you can forget about MTV as a place for discovering music.

Now I'm finding out new music from Twitter and the Internet, and I noticed one day that Christian musician David Crowder posted something on his Twitter feed about a new CD from a band called Mute Math. And, a friend who's a worship pastor also posted the same thing. 

I didn't grow up listening to Amy Grant or Michael W. Smith. I grew up listening to secular rock and roll. In the 80s, I had my full share of The Smiths, The Cure, New Order, Depeche Mode and even Bob Marley.

So I guess my background is less K-Love programming and something a little different than the mainstream. Which is why I liked Mute Math.

After doing some research, it seems some members of Mute Math where in a Christian band called Earthsuit but that band fell apart and Mute Math was formed. When their record label tried to put them in a Christian music format or market, the band objected and sued.

I can see the band's side: if you get pegged as a Christian band, then that limits you to only one national radio network and only selected venues for your shows. (Yes, a few artists can cross over, like Amy Grant, but only a handful can do it.) Says Paul Meany, the lead singer, who used to be the music director at his church:

"We've always conditioned our show universally, and (we're) just trying to speak to human beings; (we're) not really conditioning it down to Christians, and that's what the Christian music industry does. It's for a certain sect of people. I don't have anything against that--I'm one of them--but I don't want to taper it just for that," said Meany.
I can see how it would be constraining to be pigeonholed in one category. Music is music. Meany makes a good point:
But somehow you're conditioned to think no matter what you're going to do, there will be a Christian adjective in front of it. If you're gonna build houses, by God, you're gonna build Christian houses. If you're a musician, there is no other choice: You're gonna make Christian music. That's what you're gonna do. You're gonna sign to a Christian record company. You're gonna print up Christian T-shirts, whatever
There are a lot of other bands, such as Switchfoot, that are not overtly Christian but you can still get the message in the lyrics. U2 might be the most successful band with Christian musicians who aren't necessarily writing standard worship music.

Meany talks further:

“The vision of the band, and everything else, is not getting caught up in religion,” Hill said. “To me, religion is getting stuck on one thing. There’s not much freedom in religion. You’re bound to your rituals and your routines that you walk through every day. It is important to have those, but it’s also important to grow, because if you’re not moving forward, you’re standing still and then moving backward.”

Here's the crux of the matter: Labels don't matter. It doesn't matter whether your songs get played on K-Love or whatever station. What matters is what you have to say.

With that said, there's only one Mute Math song that I don't think is going down the right track. Here's a sample from "Electrify":

I'm in love with this girl
That’s got my head electrified
And I hope that someday she might go too far, go too far
Cause all I can think about is me and her electrified
I hope that someday she might take me home and lose control

Now that's not the message I would want my son to get! I don't think that music has to be preachy all the time but then again, don't lead me the wrong way. Here's what the Bible says:

Philippians 4:8 (New International Version)

 8Finally, brothers, whatever is true, whatever is noble, whatever is right, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is admirable—if anything is excellent or praiseworthy—think about such things.

If you are truly a Christian, then I don't see how your love of God and Christ cannot spill out into your music. And a key verse from the Bible is this:

Romans 1:16 (New International Version)

 16I am not ashamed of the gospel, because it is the power of God for the salvation of everyone who believes: first for the Jew, then for the Gentile.

I'll keep my eyes and ears on Mute Math for awhile but if they go towards more song lyrics like Electrify, then I'm out. Or, if their lifestyle moves towards an un-Godly way, ala Jennifer Knapp, then I don't think I could be a fan.

Your thoughts?



 

Chaos (and Everything After)

I hate cancer. Let's get that out of the way first. But after getting smashed in the crucible and coming out in complete remission after six rounds of chaos (chemotherapy), I'm not the same. I don't want to be the same.

Everything changes, coming out of the chaos. God stayed true when everything around was breaking down to chaos. I will not return to the same.

CHAOS
Muth Math

Complication is my claim to fame
I can’t believe there’ s another, constantly just another
and I can’t avoid what I can’t control
I’m losing ground, still I can’t stand down
I Know, yeah I know… Yeah

I know you stay true when my world is false
everything around’s breaking down to chaos
I always see you when my sight is lost
everything around’s breaking down to chaos

I know you stay true when my world is false
everything around’s breaking down to chaos
I always see you when my sight is lost
everything around’s breaking down to chaos

It’s hard to trust anyone again
after all the let downs I’ve been through,
haunted by what I’ve been through.

Air’s still trapped, while I still can’t breathe
and I’m screaming out, give me help somehow
I know, yeah I know… Yeah

I know you stay true when my world is false
everything around’s breaking down to chaos
I always see you when my sight is lost
everything around’s breaking down to chaos

I know you stay true when my world is false
everything around’s breaking down to chaos
I always see you when my sight is lost
everything around’s breaking down to chaos

Chaos, chaos

I know you stay true, yeah
I know you stay, yeah, yeah, yeah

I know you stay true when my world is false
everything around’s breaking down to chaos
I know you stay.

I know you stay true when my world is false
everything around’s breaking down to chaos
I know you stay.

I know you stay true and everything around’s breaking down
I know you stay true and everything around’s breaking down

I know you stay true when my world is false
everything around’s breaking down to chaos
I always see you when my sight is lost
everything around’s breaking down to chaos

I know you stay true when my world is false
everything around’s breaking down to chaos
I always see you when my sight is lost
everything around’s breaking down to chaos